We Buy All Cars, Running or Not!

Will CarMax Buy A Car with A Bad Transmission? Does CarMax Buy Cars with Mechanical Problems?

CarMax Hidden Fees When Selling a Car

One of the most common questions we receive is “will CarMax buy a car with a bad transmission?” The shortest answer is Yes, CarMax buys cars with mechanical problems and those with a bad transmission. However, your offer can be reduced significantly because any mechanical issue goes into your vehicle's evaluation process.

⚠️ If It's Broken, Don't Fix It - Get Paid Cash for Your Vehicle ⚠️

Selling a car with mechanical issues can be challenging, although many online retailers are selling used vehicles. Most private buyers are usually interested in buying a perfectly running car that doesn't have any mechanical issues.

However, if you are trying to sell a car with mechanical problems like a bad transmission, it is unlikely that you will get the used market value or Kelley Blue Book value for your vehicle.

Since CarMax is one of the largest retailers available online, there are many specific questions that people are interested in focusing on selling vehicles with mechanical problems. Thus, a question always remains will CarMax buy any car? 

This article will answer specific questions about CarMax's policy on buying cars with a bad transmission, non-running cars, damaged cars, and other Vehicles with very specific conditions. 

Will CarMax Buy A Car with A Bad Transmission?

CarMax is very common ad “We Buy All The Cars,” CarMax buys almost every vehicle, even those with significant mechanical problems.

While CarMax will accept your vehicle if it doesn't have the best transmission, you won't see any damaged vehicles when walking in any of CarMax's retail lots. CarMax cells any faulty vehicle two dealer auctions instead. 

Does CarMax buy cars with over 100 000 miles?

Mileage is never a limitation for CarMax to buy your vehicle. They will accept your vehicle even if it has over 100,000 miles. However, based on our research, any people above 130,000 miles do not go to any of CarMax's retail lots because they are immediately sold to wholesale auctions.

Unfortunately, if you decided to go with CarMax selling vehicles above 100,000 miles, you will always receive a very low offer because CarMax will not make a lot of money out of your car. Thus, if you are looking for a much higher offer, you might investigate other approaches to selling your vehicle over 100,000 miles.

For example, it might be worth investigating a junk car removal company like Cash Cars Buyer. We offer you what your vehicle deserves by comparing your car to all recent transactions around your area while considering the price of scrap metal. 

Will CarMax buy my car if I still owe money on it?

Luckily, CarMax also accepts your car even if you owe money on it. It is very similar to selling your car to a neighbor or trade-in your vehicle.

All that will happen is that CarMax will provide you with an offer and then subtract whatever you owe to the lien.

For example, if CarMax offered you $6000 for your vehicle and you still owe about $5000 on this car, CarMax will pay off the $5000 and hand you a check of $1000 only.

Similarly, if CarMax offered you $4000 for your car and you all $5000 on it, you will have to write a check for CarMax of $1000. 

Even if it's possible to sell your car to CarMax while you owe money on it, you need to evaluate the situation and see whether it's worth it or not.

For example, if you will end up paying CarMax the difference between you alone and the value of the vehicle, it might not be worth selling your vehicle to CarMax because CarMax usually provides lower than the market value.

Instead, you might need to check any available trading with a dealership focused on the same brand of your car. You might also need to check a private buyer or family member who could purchase your vehicle while taking care of the loan. 

Does CarMax buy cars with body damage?

Even if your car has body damage, CarMax will still buy it. They will try to fix it, and once your vehicle is operable, they can result on their retail lots.

However, if your vehicle is not repairable, CarMax will sell it tool and auction dealership.

Again, when selling your vehicle to CarMax, don't expect a high offer, especially for those vehicles with body damages. 

Both, if you're still asking, “will CarMax buy a car that doesn't run?” Yes, the short answer is that all this damage and mechanical issues will be considered in the evaluation process. 

Will CarMax buy a car with expired registration

Another critical question we always get regarding CarMax solid processes does CarMax registers your car with DMV, and will CarMax buy a car with expired registration?

Unfortunately, most of our investigations did not reveal any clear answer.

Some people mentioned it's not a problem, and CarMax can take care of your expired titles; others mentioned it could be a problem and prevent getting into any hassle and taking care of your expired registration.

Thus, the best answer to this question is to give CarMax a call and have a conversation with their team to get a clear answer. Otherwise, you don't want to put yourself in a lot of headaches. 

How much is a non-running car worth at CarMax?

There is no clear specific answer to this question because it depends heavily on your vehicle type, condition, and scrap metal price.

Your best guess here is to use CarMax's online appraisal to determine how much CarMax is willing to pay for your car. Then, look at CarMax appraisal versus KBB.

KBB value can be obtained from Kelley Blue Book online Calculator, where you input information about your vehicle type, condition, mileage, etc.

Then, KBB will provide you with a rough estimate about the minimum and maximum values your vehicle can make. Once you have this rough range, you can't compare it to CarMax appraisal to make sure you're not underpaid. 

Will CarMax buy a car with a bad transmission? Selling a car to CarMax review

If you're still wondering if I should sell a car to CarMax specially if it has a bad transmission, you might need to spend some time investigating what other people have to say about their experience with selling a car to CarMax bad transmission.

You can start with a quick search on Google for “selling a car with a bad transmission Reddit.” Many people posted their feedback on Reddit about how the process went and whether they recommend it or not. 

What is better than CarMax, the silver car with a bad transmission? 

If you realize that CarMax is not providing you with the best offer you are looking for, you need to evaluate the situation and compare it with other online retailers.


For example, you might need to look at Autobuy VS CarMax, Carvana VS CarMax, Vroom VS CarMax, etc.

Also, you might find private buyers who are looking for cars with bad transmission for sale. Those people might be interested in other car parts despite your vehicle's transmission problem.

Another option for you is to do the bad transmission. Many mechanics might be interested in buying your transmission even if it's bad to perform some investigations or training some of their stuff. 

Your best alternative for selling a car with a bad transmission is to reach out to Cash Cars Buyer. Cash Cars Buyer is one of the top-rated car removal companies in the nation that guarantees to fire vehicle even if it has significant transmission problems.

The great thing about Cash Cars Buyer is that we accept all cars, and we are willing to come to remove them within one to three days from your house or office while providing you with the top offers and free towing. 



In the section, we will cover additional basic questions related to “will CarMax buy a car with a bad transmission?” Some of these questions might be specific to CarMax, while others are more related to dealing with a bad transmission. 

  • Can I trade in a vehicle with a bad transmission?


Yes, there are many dealerships out there who might be interested in your car, especially if your vehicle has high demand in your area, even if your car has a bad transmission.

However, it's very important to reach out to at least three dealerships and get three appraisals before making final decisions. Dealerships tend to provide lower offers but any other car selling method in the used market.

Thus, you need to be very careful and evaluate their appraisals just like the one that makes the most sense.

Otherwise, you might need to consider other options for selling your vehicle with a bad transition, like reaching out to a junk car removal company. 

  • Who will buy a car with a bad transmission?


We will! If you have a car with a bad transmission and wondering who might accept it, Cash Cars Buyer is one of the fewest companies that guarantee to buy your car even if it has significant problems, whether related to the transition, the engine, or any other component.

  • How much can you get for a car with no transmission?


It depends. Your final offer for a vehicle with no transmission depends heavily on your vehicle's make, model, year, price of scrap metal, and who you are selling it to.

For instance, if you were selling your car with no transmission to Cash Cars Buyer, we consider this information in our evaluation process and provide you with the top offer your vehicle can make around your area. Thus, you don't need to look beyond Cash Cars Buyer! 

  • Is it worth fixing a car transmission?


Well, if fixing your transmission will cost you more than 75% of the vehicle's value, it's not worth fixing it.

Also, you need to consider whether there are any other problems in your car that could add up to the repair price. This is because even if your transmission does not cost you as high as 75% of your vehicle's value, there might be other mechanical problems that could add up to 75%. 

  • Should I fix my transmission or buy a new car?


To answer this question you need to do simple math: check how much it will cost you to fix your vehicle's transmission.

Then, check whether there are any other mechanical problems in your car and add them to the repair costs once you get a total value of required repair costs compared to your vehicle's value.

If you found that the total repair costs are getting after 75% of your vehicle's value or more, it's not worth repairing it, and instead, you would better get a new vehicle.

You don't necessarily have to buy a brand-new car; There are many used vehicles in decent condition out there in the market that you might need to check out. 

Will CarMax buy a car with a bad transmission? The bottom line 


When someone is looking for how to sell my car that needs work, things can be challenging because not everyone is interested in buying a car with mechanical problems.

Luckily, CarMax, one of the largest online retailers, accepts your vehicle even if it has significant problems like a bad transmission. However, CarMax will not provide you with the top off you are looking for, and it will usually be less than the value of the used market.

Therefore, we recommend that you get in touch with Cash Cars Buyer and compare the offer we will provide to what we will get from any other selling method. Our process is very straightforward and involves very simple steps, including: 

  • Describing your vehicles type and condition
  • Receiving, reviewing, and accepting our instant offer
  • Scheduling a pickup time and location

Getting your vehicle removed and receiving your cash payment immediately on the spot!

To get more details about our process, you can either give us a call at 866-924-4608, or you can visit our website and click on the free instant online.


© 2022 Cash Cars Buyer. All Rights Reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Sitemap