We Buy All Cars, Running or Not!

Trade in VS Private Sale: All What You Need to Know 

Trade in VS Private Sale

If you're searching for trading VS private sales, it all depends on your final goal. While with private sales, you might get extra hundreds if not thousands of dollars, the hassle involved might not be worth the extra money, and you might need to consider trade ins instead. 

Auto Repairs Are EXPENSIVE

Buying a new vehicle is a huge investment and requires a lot of analysis. Selling or trading and your old vehicle might require more work, and it can be a little challenging if you don't know everything about trade in VS private sale.

Before making your final decision, you need to consider other factors to keep in mind beyond the final amount of money or profit you'll make. For instance, the hassle involved in selling a car to a private buyer is a big deal.

This article provides it with all we need to know about trade in VS private sale. It highlights each method's main pros and cons to help you make an informed decision while considering your main goals and objectives. 

Trade in sale pros and cons 

Trading your old vehicle with the dealership is a great option, especially if you have a vehicle in mind. However, there are some things to keep in mind and consider regarding the drawbacks of cost radiance. Let's take a closer look below at some of the common pros and cons of trade in sales: 

  • Trade in pros

The 1st and most obvious advantage you will get when trading in your vehicle is reducing the hassle. When trading in your car to a dealership, they know exactly what they're doing, and they can deal with all the paperwork themselves without you spending time and effort trying to understand what needs to be signed.

Also, when you trade in your old car, you don't have to deal with two different parties for the trade in and purchasing the new vehicle.

It's very important that you consulted the dealership and confirmed that they would take care of all necessary paperwork themselves. Sometimes, the dealership might not cover everything, and you'd better go with a dealership that provides the most help if you're looking to reduce the hassle of selling your car. 

Aside from the no-hassle process with the trade ins, you don't have to worry about paying a lot on tax if your state charges some taxes. Usually, when you trade in your car, you only must pay taxes for the difference between the new car's value and the Trade in car's value. 

  • Trade in cons

One of the biggest drawbacks of trading in your old car is the offer. Usually, dealerships underestimate vehicles and will never pay you close to what the private buyer is willing to pay you.

Dealerships usually consider the amount of money they must spend on reconditioning the vehicle and the other charges for physical items like the dealership lots renting. 

Also, salespeople at dealerships are very good at negotiation, and if you don't have high skill sets in negotiation, you might not be able to get the price you're asking for. Unless you do some detailed research about the expected trade in value for the old car, you can easily slip and receive a much lower offer than what you're looking for.

Finally, trade in values can be very stressful, especially if you owe some money to your old vehicle. You might get to a situation where you're losing money instead of gaining. For example, say that you have a vehicle worth $8000, and the dealership is willing to pay you about $7000 only for this car. Then, you will pay the difference of $1000 to the dealership or to the agency you owe money to. 

Thus, it's never recommended the trade in your car unless you're 100% sure that he will make some money and it's worth it. 

Private sale pros and cons 

Similar to the trade in options, private sales also have only pros and cons. Let's take a closer look below: 

  • Private sales pros

One of the biggest advantages you will get when selling a car privately is the good offer. When you post your vehicle for sale, you are the one who decides the final ask price. Thus, no one will come by your vehicle unless they are convinced that you listed prices within their budget, although they might negotiate a little bit.

With that in mind, it's recommended that you do not post a very high ask price because it will discourage buyers from reaching out to you. You also don't want to underestimate your vehicle because it will end up not making any money.

A good rule of thumb is three forward to some of the comments tools that help you evaluate the minimum and maximum ask prize for your car. For example, you can try Kelley Blue Book instant cash offer, which also allows you to arrange for expected trade in values. With these two pieces of information, you can make a final wise decision about whether you should go with trade in VS private sale. 

  • Private sales cons

While you can make good money when selling your car privately, the process involves a lot of time and hassle. If you decided to sell your car through classified websites like Craigslist or eBay motor, you must learn certain skill sets to complete the deal successfully.

For example, you will need to learn how to create an ad and rank it on the first page so people can see it easily. Then, the only to be prepared for answering questions by email, phone, text messages from probably nonserious buyers. Finally, you will have to meet multiple strangers in your private property where many people might not find comfortable.

Another big challenge about private sales is exposing yourself to plenty of scammers through online websites like Craigslist. It's hard to tell what to expect from scammers because it could range from stealing your car to a physical attack. 

However, this does not mean that all people selling their cars through classified websites like Craigslist are in danger. It's just you must be well prepared and follow certain tips and tricks to prevent getting scammed through these classified websites. 

Can you negotiate car trading? 

Of course! As we indicated before, dealerships are looking to make extra profit no matter how. Therefore, it's recommended that you negotiate the price, and to achieve successful negotiation, you must do certain research up front.

For example, you might want to refer to Kelley Blue Book and check the minimum and maximum trade value for your own vehicle. Keep in mind that Kelley Blue Book does not consider any major mechanical problems, which means that it's your responsibility to subtract the expected mechanical repairs from the suggested Kelley Blue Book offer.

Also, before going to the dealership and having a conversation with the salesperson, it's important to receive multiple quotes from different dealerships. This way, you can better understand how much your car can make in your region. You can also use this information to your side when asking for raising the trade in value. 

Is there a minimum trade in value? 

Some dealerships might be strict their trade ins to vehicles at certain values. For example, some dealerships might say that we don't accept any trade ins for vehicles cheaper than $4000. However, that's not always the case, and it's not the norm. 

Even if there is a minimum trade in value, we recommend that you evaluate your own situation and understand exactly how much profit you can make.

Many car sellers might fall into the trap that their vehicle is worthless, and they just traded in with the dealership without making any money if not paying from their own pocket. Thus, as we mentioned earlier, make sure to get at least three quotes from multiple dealerships and do some research about how much your car is worth in another location other than the dealership itself. 

When should you wait to trade in? 

Understanding when not to trade in your car is a very important skill because it can save you thousands of dollars, if not more.

It's never recommended that you trade in a vehicle that you just purchased. This is because the vehicle loses about 20%, if not more, from its value immediately after you leave the dealership.

Also, we never recommend that you trade in your car if you pay from your pocket, especially if you all some money on this vehicle to another agency or a third party. 

Finally, there are certain seasons within the year that you might wait for two to get a better deal. For instance, sometimes of the year might involve certain discounts and sales where dealerships are trying to get out all current models in preparation for the new models. Thus, keep an eye and ear for any sales or offers from your local dealerships to determine the right time for trading in your car. 

How can I get the most money for my car trade in? 

If you still think that trade in is your best option and it's better than selling your car privately, you still need to do some research so you can get the most money out of your car. 

The whole thing depends on how much time and effort you put towards trading in your car. Are you planning to rush the process? If yes, do not expect to make any good profit.

As we indicated before, you need to research the minimum and maximum trade value your vehicle can make. Then, you recommended reaching out to multiple dealerships and understand how much they're willing to pay you.

It is also recommended that you separate the conversations about trade ins and purchasing the new vehicle because the salesperson can take advantage of you and might not provide you the best offer. This way, you can take advantage of any drop in the new vehicle price through negotiation without losing any money on your old car trade in value. 


If you search for trade in VS private sales, your final recommendation depends heavily on your own goals and objectives.

For example, if you're looking for maximum profits, you must go with private buyers. However, if you're looking for a car selling process that does not involve much hassle, trade in is a great option for you. 

If you are still unhappy about the cons of trade ins and private sales, you might consider selling your car to Cash Cars Buyer, who guarantees to buy your vehicle and paying you the top dollars with a no-hassle car selling process. 

Cash Cars Buyer is one of the top-rated car removal companies in the nation that guarantees to pay you the top dollars and will provide you with free towing despite your living location around the United States. 

Our process is very straightforward and doesn't take more than a couple of days to get your vehicle removed safely and for the most money. 

All it takes you is to:

  • Describe your vehicle’s type and condition: you will need to provide information like your vehicle's make and year. It is also important to provide a basic description of your vehicle's overall condition, including any major mechanical problems and missing components. 
  • Receive our instant free quote: our offers are quick and are usually generated within 30 seconds only! 
  • Accept the quote: we recommend that you spend as much time as you want and decide when you're 100% confident that they offer you. 
  • Get your car removed and receive your cash payment on the spot!

To learn more about our process and our teen, you can reach out to us by giving us a call at 866-924-4608 or visit our home page click on the free instant online offer.

© 2022 Cash Cars Buyer. All Rights Reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Sitemap