logo
(866) 924-4608

We Buy All Cars, Running or Not!

(866) 924-4608 FAST CASH OFFER
Is It Worth Replacing A Transmission? Five Questions to Ask Yourself

Is It Worth Replacing A Transmission? Five Questions to Ask Yourself

Are you wondering, “is it worth replacing a transmission?” Ask yourself these five questions before making a final decision:

Auto Repairs Are EXPENSIVE


  1. How much is your car worth?
  2. What is the total repair cost?
  3. How about the rest of your vehicle?
  4. Is this vehicle still suitable for you?
  5. How long are you willing to keep this vehicle?

There is nothing worse than hearing that your vehicle's transmission failed! Unfortunately, when your vehicle gets to this point, the only options would be either replacing the transmission or installing a rebuilt one.

If you don't already know, transmission replacement costs thousands of dollars, and deciding whether to replace the transmission or not requires some research and patience. There are plenty of factors that you should consider when making this decision, and without asking yourself other questions, you might waste your money on a vehicle that is not worth it.

This article provides you with all details you need to know before deciding on transmission replacement. In addition, it highlights the expected transmission replacement costs, reasons why transmission replacement costs are very high, and questions to ask yourself before replacing your transmission. This way, you can be very confident and sure about the question of “is it worth replacing a transmission?”

How much does it cost to fix the transmission?

Before we dive into the details about “is it worth replacing a transmission,” let's get a general idea about how much it will cost you to replace the transmission or rebuild it. In general, replacing the transmission should cost somewhere between $1000 again $7000. But, of course, this price range differs significantly depending on your vehicle's type.


For example, if you're driving a luxury car, expect to pay up to $10,000, if not more, to replace the transmission. However, if you're driving a small sedan car, the placement cost will be much lower, and the approach is about $2800 only.

Why are transmission repairs very expensive?

As you might notice, transmission replacement is not a simple, cheap job, and it's a huge investment to many drivers. Therefore, one might wonder why is it so expensive to replace the vehicle's transmission? Of course, we might understand that the part itself is expensive but are there any other factors that could impact replacing the transmission?

Let's take a closer look at all factors that could go into the transmission replacement costs:

1.    Your vehicle's manufacturer

The first most important element in deciding how much you can pay for replacing the transmission is the manufacturing. The modern new vehicle is the highest price because the translations are more sophisticated and require thousands of interacting components.

Also, certain manufacturers generally produce more expensive transmissions than others, even if they are not as complicated as competitors. Furthermore, the same manufacturer might produce more expensive transmissions if they are automatic versus manual.

2.    Your vehicle's age

The first thing that comes to mind is that the more modern the vehicle is, the more expensive it is to replace the transmission. While this is the common case, there are many instances where finding a transmission can be extremely rear and hard if your vehicle is very old. Therefore, you might want to pay much more than someone looking for a transmission replacement for a modern vehicle.

3.    Transmission type

As we had before, if you're driving a vehicle with a manual transmission, expect to pay less than someone else who is driving a vehicle with an automatic transmission.

4.    Your address

Some factors have to do with the location where you live, and those factors also go into the final transmission replacement costs. So certain areas around New York or probably Colorado are expected to have more expensive transmission replacements than other areas in Alabama.

5.    The location will get the job done

Finally, deciding where to get the transmission replacement also plays a role in how much you're going to pay for a transmission replacement. For example, if you decided to have an independent shop replace your transmission, repair costs will be much lower than someone else was having the transmission replaced at a dealership. Again, this is because the pay rate is much lower at the independent shop than at the dealership.

However, you mustn't put the price as the priority for you because when it comes to replacing the transmission, you want to make sure that the job is done correctly and there are no mistakes introduced to cause damages that could cost you a lot of money.

Is it worth replacing a transmission? 5 questions to ask yourself

Now you have a good understanding of the transmission replacement costs and the reasons why it's very expensive, the next question you must ask yourself is, “is it worth replacing a transmission?”

To help you better answer this question, you must ask yourself some other simple questions that lead you to an accurate decision and prevent you from wasting your money on transmission repair when it's not worth it. So let's take a closer look at these questions below:

1.    How much is your car worth?

When asking yourself if it is worth replacing a transmission, you need to understand your vehicles currently. Once our vehicles get older, their value is not the same as when we first purchased them. In other words, if you purchased an expensive vehicle five years ago, you might still be thinking that it's very expensive and it's worth installing in the transmission. However, that might not necessarily be the case.

Therefore, it is recommended that you go through some common websites like Kelley Blue Book or probably advanced.com to get an idea about your vehicle's current value. These websites allow you to input basic information about your car and provide you with an instant colt representing how much your vehicle can make.

It is important to note that the KBB value does not consider any maintenance costs. In other words, if you know for sure that your vehicle has a transmission problem or any other problems, it's going to be your job to subtract these problems costs from the KBB value to get an accurate estimation of your vehicle's current value.

2.    What is the total repair cost?

After understanding your vehicle's current worth, the next step is to carefully note that the total repair costs should cover the transmission replacement and any other problems in your vehicle. For example, if your car requires tire rotation or engine cleanup, you should Add all these values together and calculate a total repair cost.

If your vehicle only suffers from a transmission problem, any transmission replacement court should cover the issue and give you an idea about the expected repair costs.

3.    How about the rest of your vehicle?

If you've been driving your vehicle for a couple of years, you should have a good idea about whether the vehicle was taken care of we met. In other words, if you've been taking good care of your vehicle and never skipped an oil change, it might be worth investing in replacing the transmission.

On the other hand, if you've purchased this vehicle as used and you know that it hasn't been taken care of, it might be just the time for your vehicle to go. Before we can make your final decision, it could be worth having your mechanic tickles or look at the car and let you know whether the vehicle suffers from other major problems and whether it's worth replacing the transmission or not.

4.    Is this vehicle still suitable for you?

The other thing to consider is whether your vehicle suits your needs nowadays or not. Probably you purchased this car five years ago when you didn't have a family or children, and now, you're looking for an upgrade that fits all your family members. If that's the case, why would you waste your money installing a new transmission in a vehicle that won't serve your needs?

5.    How long are you willing to keep this vehicle?

Like the previous questions, you also need to consider whether you’re planning to keep the vehicle longer or not. For instance, if you currently don't have children and you're expecting within the next couple of months, then you will end up needing a new vehicle, and that's where it's not worth replacing the transmission. It's not worth putting these thousands of dollars on a vehicle that will not help you.

What can go wrong with your transmission, and how much does it cost to fix?

Before you get nervous about transmission repair costs, you must familiarize yourself with the different problems that your transmission may face and whether these problems are repairable or not. For example, you might be dealing with an issue that requires only a couple of hundreds of dollars to get fixed rather than installing a new transmission.

Let's take it also a look at some of the common transmission problems or transmission maintenance that you might deal with:

1.    Transmission fluid flush

Your vehicle's transmission relies on a certain fluid that could be part of how it operates, or it could be useful for lubricating the entire components, which depends heavily on your vehicle's transmission type.

Over time abuse, this transmission fluid gets dirtier and becomes suitable for serving its needs. Therefore, you'll need to flush this transmission completely and replace it with a fresh one that helps protect it and make it work efficiently.

If all your transmission problems have to do with transmission flush, don't worry because your maintenance costs should be close to $300. However, you might get transferred flushed somewhere between $75 and $150 depending on where you get the shotgun and whether you're planning to do it yourself or by a professional.

2.    Transmission fluid leak

It's not rare to deal with transmission fluid leaks at some point in time, and when this happens, you must take care of the issue immediately, so you don't get to a point where you have to ask yourself is it worth replacing a transmission when the transmission fails.

Fixing transmission fluid leaks should cost you somewhere between $150 and $200 here, and of course, the leak might be severe, and it could be in many different locations around the transmission, and that's where repair costs can become higher.

3.    Damaged solenoid

Finally, the transmission Solenoid might get broken or damaged at some point, and when that happens, you'll need to replace it. Typically, solenoids replacement is one of the cheapest when it comes to transmission problems, and it should cost you somewhere between $20 a $100.

When is transmission repair not worth it?

After asking yourself the five questions we highlighted before, you should have had that idea about answering the question of is it worth replacing a transmission fear in figure typically, if you found that repair costs are piling up and getting close to 75% or more from your vehicles value, it is not worth replacing the transmission.

However, if the transmission issue is the only thing your vehicle is dealing with and your vehicle is valuable to you, it is worth fixing it because you don't have any other choice. Your vehicle won't be drivable unless you have a good transmission.

Is it worth replacing a transmission? Final thoughts

Since transmission replacement is a very expensive repair job, asking yourself, “is it worth replacing a transmission” is the first step towards the solution.

This article highlighted five questions you should ask yourself to make an informed decision about whether to replace the transmission or not. However, if you get to a point where you feel that it's not worth the repair, you went out to consider selling this vehicle and using its value to buy a better car that doesn't have any major problems.

Did you know that it's very hard to find a private buyer who accepts buying your vehicle with a transmission problem? Yes! However, that's not the end of the world because cash cars buyer is one of the few companies that guarantee to buy your car no matter what!

Cash Cars Buyer is willing to remove your vehicle within one to three days only! Cash Cars Buyer is one of the top-rated car removal companies in the nation that guarantees to pay you the top dollars and provide you with free towing despite your living location around the United States.

Our process is very straightforward and doesn't take more than a couple of days to get your car removed safely and for the most money.

All it takes you is to:

  • Describe your car’s type and condition
  • Receive our instant free quote
  • Accept the quote
  • Get your car removed and receive your cash payment on the spot!

To learn more about our process and our teen, you can reach out to us by giving us a call at 866-924-4608 or visit our home page click on the free instant online offer.